The following is my (Joe Beaudoin Jr.’s) own personal opinion… the opinion of my fellow contributors and chiefs may differ.
I’ve been asked by various people why we don’t have our own “mailing list” or “chat room”, or somewhere where Wiki contributors can hang out and discuss Wiki stuff, well, off-wiki. (Just recently, one of our contributors brought up having a “chat room” for contributors, so that was part of the impetus for this blog.)
I’ve also been asked why I’ve been resistant to deploying a forum and completely integrate that into Battlestar Wiki… I’ll reveal why.
I’ve come across this article that reveals what I’ve long suspected about Wikipedia, that it has behind-the-scenes mailing lists whereby top contributors discuss what they’re going to do on Wikipedia in terms of bans, edits, etc. Unfortunately, it uses such channels in a negative manner, which has its community (rightfully) in an uproar.
I’m not going to go into the reasons why we don’t have a chat room or a Battlestar Wiki mailing list, because such tools are ultimately unnecessary in light of the features that MediaWiki provides… moreover, it’s because of what is outlined in the article above.
Yet in the interests of full disclosure, I’ll reveal that we do have a “hidden” forum on Battlestar Forum. I will point out that it is for Frak Media productions, where we discuss new projects and discuss issues that legally (yeah, as in “the law”) can’t be discussed in the open for various reasons. We don’t make decisions on the direction of the Wiki’s content in said “hidden” forum and we sure as hell don’t make decisions there regarding banning people.
In this, I guess you can call me Captain Transparency, because I believe that things that grow in the dark tend to be bad, particularly if left to people without ethics or accountability.
At the same time, I will say that I find that sometimes there are conversations you have to have with people behind closed doors, because there are private, personal things that don’t need to be aired out for public scrutiny… So, really like anything else, it’s not what tools you use, it’s ultimately how you use them. After all, you can use a hammer to bang in a nail… or to smash someone’s skull in. Unfortunately, Wikipedia’s secret mailing list seems to fall under the latter category.
And that’s sad for a tool that’s supposed to “not make people sad” or the “Internet not suck“.